Each type of ice does a different job. Block ice lasts, cubes cool quickly, and dry ice is a different material altogether that demands real safety care.
Block ice melts more slowly because there is less surface area exposed to warm air compared with the same amount of water frozen as small cubes. That makes it a good choice for multi-day trips where the cooler has to hold up without a restock.
You can buy blocks at some stores or make your own by freezing water in a large container or jug. Homemade blocks in reusable containers have a side benefit: when they melt, you have clean drinking-grade water if the container is food-safe and you started with clean water. The tradeoff is that a big block cools the contents slowly and takes up a lot of space, so it is best paired with a quicker ice.
A practical tip: freeze water in a clean, food-safe container with a lid, and leave a little room at the top for expansion. Containers with a wide mouth are easier to fill and empty.
Cubes and crushed ice flow into the gaps between cans and food, which is why they chill things quickly. The same surface area that cools quickly also melts quickly, so cubed ice suits short trips, parties and day outings where speed matters more than longevity.
Because cubes pack in tightly, they also help remove air pockets. That makes them handy as a top layer or a gap filler even on longer trips.
If you are filling a cooler at a store ice machine or freezer, cubed ice is the usual choice and costs little effort. Keep a bag unopened in a second cooler or in the shade if you want a backup for the second day, and avoid letting it sit in a hot car on the way.
A common approach is a hybrid: block ice or frozen jugs on the bottom for staying power, and cubed ice around and above the contents to chill things fast and fill gaps. You get the quick start of cubes and the lasting power of the block. The packing guide shows where each layer goes.
Whatever mix you use, a pre-chilled cooler, shade and a tight pack matter at least as much as the ice type. The guide on keeping a cooler cold has the details.
| Ice type | Cools | Lasts | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Block ice | Slowly | Longest of the three ice types we cover without special handling | Multi-day trips |
| Cubed or crushed ice | Quickly | Shorter | Day trips, parties, quick chilling |
| Dry ice | Extremely cold | Disappears as gas | Frozen goods, with strict safety rules |
For a single afternoon, a bag or two of cubed ice does the job, and you do not have to think much about it. For a weekend, add a block or a few frozen jugs to the bottom so you are not racing the melt. For multiple days, plan to restock, and think about a better-insulated cooler, because even good ice only goes so far.
Consider what you are cooling too. Drinks respond well to cubes and cold water because the liquid surrounds the cans. Frozen food that needs to stay frozen is where some people reach for dry ice, but it brings handling rules that regular ice does not. Many casual campers can skip it completely.
Frozen water jugs behave like homemade block ice with a bonus: the meltwater is drinkable if you started with clean water in a clean food-safe container. Reusable freezer packs are another option. They do not leak water, which keeps food dry, but they usually do not cool as long as a block of ice of similar size, so treat them as a supplement.
Whatever you choose, freeze it solid before the trip and keep the pre-chilled cooler closed until you load it.
Dry ice is solid carbon dioxide. It does not melt into water. It changes directly into carbon dioxide gas, a process called sublimation, at about minus 109 degrees Fahrenheit (minus 78 degrees Celsius). That temperature is far colder than the freezing point of water, which is what makes dry ice useful for keeping things frozen and also what makes it dangerous to handle.
Dry ice can freeze skin on contact. Never handle it with bare hands. Use insulated or cryogenic-style gloves that are loose enough to pull off quickly, and wear eye protection. If a part of your body freezes, do not rub it, since that can damage tissue. Remove clothing that is not frozen to the skin, warm the area gently in a warm water bath (not hot), and get medical help.
Dry ice is also not a drop-in swap for regular ice. It does not leave water behind, it will freeze anything it touches, and it changes how long you need to ventilate your vehicle. If you are not sure you need it, you probably do not. Rules for buying and transporting dry ice vary, so ask the seller about handling and anything that applies to your trip.
As dry ice turns to gas, the carbon dioxide has to go somewhere. Never seal dry ice in an airtight container, because pressure can build up and cause an explosion. A cooler with a lid that is not locked down airtight, or one with a vent open, is a safer choice, and an insulated container where gas can escape is the general guidance.
Do not use or store dry ice in a confined, unventilated space. In a closed car, van, or room, carbon dioxide can build up and displace the air you need. If dry ice has been in a closed vehicle or room for a while, open the doors and let it air out before getting in. Symptoms of too much carbon dioxide include faster breathing, headache and drowsiness. If you notice those, get into fresh air right away, and call 911 or your local emergency number if symptoms are serious.
Keep dry ice away from children and pets, and do not put it in drinks or let it touch skin. Let any leftover dry ice sublimate in a well-ventilated area, not in a sink, closed room or drain.
Liquids expand as they freeze, and a can pressed against dry ice can freeze solid, bulge or split. If you do use dry ice in a cooler with drinks, keep it wrapped and separated from the cans, using paper or a divider, and place it above or beside the items instead of under them so cold gas falls over them without direct contact. Many people avoid dry ice with drinks altogether and use regular ice for those. A divider is exactly the type of thing that helps keep things apart.
Block ice melts more slowly because it has less surface area exposed to warm air. Cubed ice cools faster but melts sooner.
It can be used, but it needs care. Wear gloves and eye protection, never seal it in an airtight container, and keep the area ventilated. Keep it from touching cans.
Avoid carrying it in a sealed passenger cabin. Carbon dioxide gas can build up. Ventilate the vehicle and air it out if dry ice has been inside a closed space.
Yes. Cans in contact with dry ice can freeze, bulge or split. Keep dry ice wrapped and separated from drinks, or use regular ice for the drink cooler.
Tell us which products you want and we will write when they are ready or when we have an update.